Aug 22, 2017 they eviscerated the book by making it an action movie for young people aged 15 to 25, christopher says regretfully. I find they are better on some level, or just as good as the trilogy for the following reason. Commentators have compared peter jacksons 20012003 the lord of the rings film trilogy with the book on which it was based, j. Bilbo is quite content at bag end, near the bustling hobbit village of hobbiton, but one day his comfort is shattered by the arrival of the old wizard gandalf, who persuades. Of course, both have their ups and downs, so theres been some heated debate on lord of the rings books vs. An admirable and thoughtprovoking consideration of the underlying themes of the hobbit, following the thereandbackagain progress from its famous first line on through to bilbos return home at the storys end. Mar 18, 2021 due to the jackson additions to the hobbit movies that directly foreshadow events in the lotr, there are some scenes in the hobbit that ruin parts of the lord of the rings series, but for a firsttime watcher, it is hard for you to even notice those things, and there will be much more spoilers if you go by release order. Commentators have compared peter jackson s 20012003 the lord of the rings film trilogy with the book on which it was based, j. The hobbit film trilogy the one wiki to rule them all fandom.
Find books like the hobbit, or there and back again from the worlds largest community of readers. So when the journey got to the final battle with the actual. The other main issue with the hobbit trilogy is that many of the characters arent that likeable. Check out the trilogy s worst changes from page to screen. In which we look back at the hobbit trilogy and try to give it a fair shake. Watching peter jacksons the hobbit trilogy for the first time. Series page for the hobbit published in volumes the hobbit, part one, the hobbit, part 2 of 2, and the hobbit, or there and back again. In most cases, i find books far superior to their screen. Tolkien 18921973 is the creator of middleearth and author of such classic and extraordinary works of fiction as the hobbit, the lord of the rings, and the silmarillion. The complete list of film changes is my ongoing project to list all the reported differences between peter jacksons hobbit and lord of the rings films and the j. It was published on 21 september 1937 to wide critical acclaim, being nominated for the carnegie medal and awarded a prize from the new york herald tribune for best juvenile fiction. The complete list of film changes for the lord of the rings.
In july 2010 he finished filming series 9, due to be broadcast in late september. A reluctant hobbit, bilbo baggins, sets out to the lonely mountain with a spirited group of dwarves to reclaim their mountain home, and the. On the other hand, others prefer peter jacksons visual epic spectacle. Tolkien actually presented it originally as one book. Its been some 30 years since i read the hobbit, but im pretty certain she was exaggerating. Many fans didnt like the expansion of arwen and the romance in the lord of the rings trilogy and cited that legolas never married and was a lifelong companion with gimli, son of gloin. No offense to fans of the movies, but the threepart hobbit adaptation sort of proved christopher right. Oct 20, 2019 diehard tolkien fans swear by the book and criticize the movie for the numerous changes. Book and film differences the hobbit wiki guide ign. Tolkien, the world of middleearth has captured the imaginations of readers and been the setting for some of the worlds best loved. His books have been translated into more than fifty languages and have sold many millions of copies worldwide. Tolkien intended the hobbit to be a childrens book j. Nov 24, 2014 ah, the elvenkingchrismas is coming and we will probably see the last new movie from middle earth for decades to come.
Jan 28, 2015 the hobbit was actually written as a childrens book and the tone and substance are in key with that. Dec 01, 2020 the hobbit trilogy on 4k finally makes peter jacksons prequels look like real movies with stunning, cinematic visuals. This happens in the book, but here it feels a bit weird, forced, and conveniently resolved. On top of all that, he brings the film full circle, ending his hobbit trilogy where the lord of the rings begins it was sheer brilliance. As five great armies go to war, bilbo fights for his life, and the races of dwarves, elves and men must unite or be destroyed.
The ironfoot edition and these are the edits that probably exist, but im having a hard time finding a copy of. In the hobbit films, gandalf only learns of the necromancer when he speaks to radagast, which is what peter jackson. Jul 26, 2012 15 years ago, when peter jackson first set out to make a movie adaptation of j. The best way to read tolkiens hobbit and lord of the. Well, considering that they took about 25 pages of the book and turned it into a 2 hour movie, not terrible.
Peter jacksons bekroonde the hobbittrilogie inclusief the unexpected. In march 2009, armitage began filming for series 8 of spooks, which began airing in november 2009. In may of 2010, he starred as john porter in strike back for sky 1. Tolkien s 19541955 the lord of the rings, remarking that while both have been extremely successful commercially, they differ in many respects. The goblin king and the whole fight scene was over the top and cartoonish, a total turnoff. I tried giving the hobbit trilogy a chance, but it just hurts so much.
This had all the ingredients to be great but peter jacksons idiosyncrasies and obsessions got in the way. The hobbit, or there and back again is a childrens fantasy novel by english author j. I am attempting to document each difference, regardless of whether i personally consider them to be good or bad, major or trivial. The battle of the five armies the final chapter in peter jacksons trilogy strays furthest from the book, but there are still a few buried easter. Book depository books with free delivery worldwide. The lord of the rings trilogy vs the hobbit trilogy. After writing one of his most popular books of the time, the hobbit, in 1937, tolkien began work on his great trilogy that same year. The lord of the rings trilogy worked because there were three books for jackson to work with. If book fans dont seem to remember azog the pale orc from the. Fan proves the hobbit only needed to be one movie after all. Why is the hobbit movie trilogy so bad, compared to the. Martin freeman, ian mckellen, richard armitage, andy serkis. Tolkiens 1937 novel, which i had not opened since i was a teenager.
A meek hobbit from the shire and eight companions set out on a journey to destroy the powerful one ring and save middleearth from the dark lord sauron. Difference between lord of the rings and the hobbit compare. That thought makes me a little sad, especially since i came to regard the hobbit trilogy as a wasted potential. The hobbit got published in 1937 while the lord of the rings was published in 195455. Books similar to the hobbit, or there and back again. Why the hobbit trilogy isnt as loved as the lord of the. On 20 may 2009, he also appeared in the bbc1 drama moving on as john mulligan. The hobbit is a film series consisting of three high fantasy adventure films directed by peter jackson. Peter jacksons adaptation of jrr tolkiens hobbit was not a faithful one. The complete list of film changes for the lord of the. The hobbit trilogy consists of three films an unexpected journey, the desolation of smaug, and the battle of the five armies. The six disc 4k ultra high definition bluray trilogy movie of peter jacksons hobbit trilogy, arrived today and undamaged. Lotr, which was written as a heavy sequel, is far darker and the characters are far more 3 dimensional. Why is the hobbit movie so different from the book.
Tolkiens 19541955 the lord of the rings, remarking that while both have been extremely successful commercially, they differ in many respects critics have admired jacksons ability to film the long and complex work at all. The lord of the rings and the hobbit movies in order. A reluctant hobbit, bilbo baggins, sets out to the lonely mountain with a spirited group of dwarves to reclaim their mountain home, and the gold within it from the dragon smaug. Elijah wood, ian mckellen, orlando bloom, sean bean. Thats still with most of postproduction to complete on the third film. A lot of people love entertainment that they do not have to put too much thought into. Some people dont quite like it, but feel there is a good movie in there somewhere. The hobbit trilogy bluray region free uk import uv not available 4.
That is one of the main reasons why it is called entertainment. Peter jacksons the lords of the rings lotr and the hobbit movie trilogies have been great commercial successes. Dec 06, 2012 with the imminent release of the first of peter jacksons threepart adaptation of the hobbit, i revisited j. Goodreads members who liked the hobbit, or there and b. Sure theyre likable, playful and wise, but i defy any tolkien fan to quote a shire bon mot that doesnt have.
Jul 30, 2012 jackson made the lord of the rings trilogy with a one book to one film ratio. The scene with the trolls was humorous in the book, but. The motion picture trilogy theatrical versions dvd. Difference between lord of the rings and the hobbit. The events taking place in the hobbit are shown on a smaller scale than the events in the lord of the rings.
Extended edition trilogy dvd this product ad may change over time. Though the series was published way back in 1954 and 1955, admirers of the chain cant get enough of tolkiens legendary world. And it seems that the hobbit will be the same kind of film. However, since each tome blitzed the 100,000 word mark the fellowship of the ring has177,227 words, the two towers. The scale of events in the hobbit was always smaller than lotr, which is about the ultimate battle of their era. Those who have read both the lord of the rings as well as the hobbit know that there is a great difference in the tone and the tenor of the two novels, but with peter jackson being in charge of the first two films made under the name of hobbit, there is a conscious attempt to replicate the success of the earlier trilogy of lord of the rings by inserting some of the characters of those movies in the new hobbit movies. The book remains popular and is recognized as a classic in childrens. The dwarfed edition the tolkien edit there and back again killstein there and back again a hobbit s cut the hobbit. This boxst contains all three hobbit movies, a journey there and back again a hobbits tale, the desolaution of smaug and the battle of the five armies, in stunning 4k uhd bluray and a dolby atmos soundtrack for all three. Peter jacksons threepart attempt to become george lu. The hobbit trilogy steelbook 4k ultra hd bluray, andy. The hobbit book was intended, and is still catalogued, as a childrens book, or a story meant for a younger audience.
Mar 01, 2020 someone finally took the hobbit trilogy away from peter jackson at least figuratively and gave tolkien fans the movie they deserve a decade ago, we could have never imagined wanting jackson. Bilbo lives in a hole because he is a hobbit one of a race of small, plump people about half the size of humans, with furry toes and a great love of good food and drink. What portions of the book are in each hobbit movie. The battle of the five armiestm the dwarves of erebor have reclaimed their homeland, but face the consequences of unleashing smaug. Tolkiens classic fantasy series the lord of the rings, the director could barely get a twomovie version. The fellowship of the ring was far from being on target. The changes brought about by peter jackson, director of the hobbit trilogy, add depth to the story and more or less meet the expectations of fans of the lord of the rings films.
Dec 19, 2014 the tolkien nerds guide to the hobbit. In the book, gandalf tricks the trolls into not eating the dwarves until the sun rises, which turns the trolls to stone. An unexpected journey back in december 2012 centered around whether or not the new trilogy was artistically necessary, whether or not it was reasonable to. Episode v the empire strikes back 4k ultra hd blur.
1152 979 928 622 658 690 1676 919 510 1685 715 342 1110 1284 721 311 473 1028 848 1318 1340 100